Your users are complaining that the site is loading slowly. Requests to your application are hanging. With so many possible causes of request hangs, its difficult to know where to even start.
I have been helping people with hanging requests for a long time, first at Microsoft, and now at LeanSentry. My first step is always to reproduce and observe the problem. Once you do that, you know what you are dealing with and can formulate an effective plan to fix it.
I see lots of people using the “stab in the dark” method, blindly guessing at things or worse yet making code changes to fix what “they think” it is. This usually just ends up wasting their day/week. And often with little to show for it at the end.
Here is my preferred method for diagnosing hanging requests on IIS servers:
1. Dump hanging requests
%windir%system32inetsrvappcmd list requests /elapsed:30000
If the requests are currently hanging, this will instantly show you 3 critical things:
1. Which URLs are involved
2. Whether all requests to the app are hanging or just specific URLs
3. The module/request stage they are hanging in.
2. Next, get a detailed request trace
The request trace for the hanging request will give you more information about where the request is hanging.
Also, Failed Request Tracing can be used to capture the hanging requests if you are unable to catch it in real time. You can use it to set rules that capture traces when requests to specific URLs exceed a time limit, or fail with specific errors, etc.
When we were working on IIS 7.0, Jaro (the developer on Failed Request Tracing) and I often talked about the primary weakness of FRT for troubleshooting: that you had to modify the application configuration in order to configure the tracing rules. If you had a problem and configured trace rules to capture a trace, the resulting configuration change would restart the application and would likely reset whatever problem condition you were trying to trace. I was always a big advocate of allowing server variables to be used to turn on tracing at runtime, so that I could then at least write a module to dynamically enable traces without touching configuration. Unfortunately, this was never done for the FRT feature. This was one of the reasons that we built a custom trace provider for LeanSentry, that is hosted completely outside of the IIS application and cannot affect it.
To enable FRT rules, run:
%windir%system32inetsrvappcmd configure trace "Default Web Site" /enablesite
%windir%system32inetsrvappcmd configure trace "Default Web Site" /enable /path:test.aspx /timeTaken:00:00:30
Then, after a while, if you were lucky enough to capture the traces, you can find them like this:
appcmd list traces | findstr "test.aspx"
When I wrote AppCmd, I added the ability to specify search filters by doing things like /url:$=*test.aspx* for any parameter. This was not a planned feature at the time (many AppCmd features I added werent), so I got quite a bit of pushback from the test team on it. The unfortunate result for this is that the list traces command did not receive this functionality, which makes it harder to quickly search FRT traces using appcmd. Hence the hacky usage of findstr instead.
Once you have the trace, you can quickly bring up the trace with this trick:
appcmd list traces "Default Web Site/fr000003.xml" /text:path > temp.bat && temp.bat
Head over to the “Complete request trace” tab to view the events leading up to the hang. Keep in mind that the trace cuts out on the last event before the timeout hit (another unfortunate but easily understandable design decision). This always confuses people expecting to see a big fat “30 seconds spent here!”. The last event should give you an idea of where the hang started.
3. Diagnose it
At this point, you already have a lot of information about what’s happening. You just don’t know why yet. Here are the questions I usually ask:
1. Are all requests to the application hanging or just requests to specific URLs?
If all, I look for typical signs of an overloaded or deadlocked application (resource overload, threadpool starvation, application deadlock). If some, I look for what is causing the request to hang in the application code.
2. Where is the request hanging?
For application-level overload, this usually happens at the beginning of the request processing pipeline (where the request is queued) vs. the ExecuteRequestHandler stage for application code hangs. Differentiating this could sometimes get tricky but it is usually straightforward.
3. Is the request is hung in application code?
You’ll typically see these hanging in the “ExecuteRequestHandler” stage. Then, you’ll need to either be very good at guessing, or break out a debugger to see exactly where the request is stuck.
Guess which approach I usually use Of course, debugging in production is an art in itself and is outside of the scope of this post. For the debugger to work, you also need to be able to repro the problem or be lucky to catch it live. We have several techniques we use for rapid debugging, which I’ll blog about in a later post.
Bottom line, hanging or slow requests are a reality for web applications. Its going to happen sooner or later.
The right way to deal with this is to have a continuous monitoring tool in place that catches slow requests whenever they happen, and helps you determine the cause of the hang (obligatory plug: that’s exactly what we built LeanSentry for).
Otherwise you better be ready to spend some time trying to catch the problem, and then roll up your sleeves and bust out some good old troubleshooting techniques.